Typing Safari · English

The Dvorak Keyboard: Promise, Politics, and the 1944 Navy Study

· Typing Safari

In 1936, August Dvorak, an educational psychologist at the University of Washington, and his brother-in-law William Dealey received a US patent for a keyboard layout meant to make QWERTY obsolete. The two spent years studying letter frequencies, hand movements, and typing errors before they settled on the arrangement. Their Dvorak Simplified Keyboard put the most common English letters on the home row: all five vowels (A, O, E, U, I) under the left hand and the frequent consonants D, H, T, N, S under the right.

Designing a keyboard by time-and-motion study

The method came from industrial engineering. In 1914 Dealey saw a demonstration by Frank and Lillian Gilbreth, the time-and-motion pioneers who filmed workers in slow motion to study fatigue and wasted movement, and Dvorak and Dealey later used a similar approach to study the movements of typists. Their conclusion was that QWERTY made fingers travel too far, kept them off the home row, and gave the left hand more than its share of the work: on QWERTY about 56 percent of keystrokes fall to the left hand, while on Dvorak the right hand does about 56 percent.

On Dvorak's layout (US Patent 2,040,248, granted May 12, 1936), roughly 70 percent of keystrokes stay on the home row, compared with about 32 percent on QWERTY. Because the vowels sit on one side and the common consonants on the other, typing English tends to alternate between the hands.

The layout's most famous champion was Barbara Blackburn. She began using Dvorak in 1938, while training as a demonstrator for the simplified keyboard at a business college in Kansas City, and said the switch took her about three weeks. The 1985 Guinness Book of World Records credited her with maintaining 150 words per minute for 50 minutes and reaching 170 WPM on the Dvorak keyboard, and she claimed 212 WPM for a brief time on an Apple keyboard. Guinness dropped her entry the following year, saying that records on electric and computer typewriters could not be compared with any accuracy.

The 1944 US Navy study controversy

During World War II, Lieutenant Commander August Dvorak served as a time-and-motion expert for the US Navy, and in 1944 he conducted a retraining experiment. The Navy report claimed that typists retrained on Dvorak increased their speed by 75 percent, against a 28 percent gain for a group given extra QWERTY training, and that the cost of retraining would be paid back within about ten days. That result became Dvorak's strongest selling point for decades.

In the mid-1950s, the US General Services Administration (GSA) commissioned a new study from Earle Strong, a professor at Pennsylvania State University. Strong's 1956 experiment, with ten typists in each group, found Dvorak no more efficient than QWERTY. He concluded that retraining typists on Dvorak was inferior to giving them more QWERTY training and would never pay back its cost. Strong's critics have argued that he was biased against Dvorak, so neither study settled the question cleanly.

Later, economists Stan Liebowitz and Stephen Margolis pointed out in "The Fable of the Keys" (1990) that the Navy test had been run by Dvorak himself, who owned the patent on the layout and had received research money to study it. In their reading, the best-documented experiments suggest little or no advantage for the Dvorak keyboard.

Why QWERTY stayed on top

Even if Dvorak reduces finger travel, switching an entire workforce carries retraining costs, and the evidence that the switch would pay for itself was disputed. Typewriters, schools, offices, and eventually computers kept reinforcing QWERTY's lead. Today, Windows, macOS, and Linux all include Dvorak as a built-in layout, and iOS added it in 2022, so anyone curious can try it without buying special hardware.

Typing Safari teaches touch typing in English on your own keyboard in its lessons, and you can check your current speed with the free speed test, no account needed.

FAQ

Who invented the Dvorak keyboard and when?

August Dvorak and his brother-in-law William Dealey developed the layout over many years of research and received US Patent 2,040,248 on May 12, 1936.

Is Dvorak actually faster than QWERTY?

Dvorak puts about 70 percent of keystrokes on the home row, against about 32 percent on QWERTY, and many typists find it more comfortable. The speed evidence is contested: Dvorak's own 1944 Navy study claimed a 75 percent gain, while Earle Strong's 1956 study for the GSA found Dvorak no more efficient than QWERTY.

Why is the 1944 Navy study controversial?

It was conducted by August Dvorak himself, who held the patent on the layout. Economists Stan Liebowitz and Stephen Margolis argued that this, along with the way the study was run, makes its 75 percent figure unreliable.

Can I switch to Dvorak on a modern computer?

Yes. Windows, macOS, and Linux all include Dvorak as a built-in software keyboard layout, though you may want to keep a chart of the layout nearby while learning.

Sources

More from the blog