Typing Safari · English

Hunt-and-Peck vs. 10-Finger Touch Typing: What Science Actually Found

· Typing Safari

For over a century, typing teachers have preached one golden rule: keep all ten fingers on the home row, never look down, and use the assigned finger for every key. Yet almost everyone knows someone who glances at the keys, uses a handful of fingers in their own improvised style, and still types fast. In 2016, researchers at Aalto University set out to measure what was really going on.

The Aalto University study that surprised everyone

Anna Maria Feit, Daryl Weir, and Antti Oulasvirta studied 30 everyday typists, typing in Finnish or English, using motion capture (52 markers on the hands, recorded at 240 frames per second), keypress logging, and eye-tracking glasses. They presented the work, "How We Type", at the ACM CHI conference in 2016. Based on what participants reported, 43% had learned the touch typing system; the rest had never taken a typing course.

The result surprised the researchers themselves. The participants typed between 34 and 79 words per minute, and there was no significant difference in speed between the two groups: touch typists averaged 57.8 WPM and self-taught typists 58.9 WPM. Self-taught typists used about six fingers on average (6.2, against 8.5 for touch typists), and even some participants who used only one or two fingers per hand reached speeds normally attributed to touch typists. In the authors' words, an everyday typist may achieve entry rates over 70 WPM regardless of the number of fingers used.

What did the fast typists have in common, whatever their style? The study named three predictors of speed: pressing each letter consistently with the same finger, preparing upcoming keystrokes in advance, and keeping the hands steady rather than moving them around the keyboard.

Where 10-finger touch typing pulls ahead

So if an improvised style can match touch typing on speed, why learn it? The same study found real differences:

  1. Eyes on the screen, not the keys. Self-taught typists spent about twice as much time looking at the keyboard: 41% of the time, against 20% for touch typists. Touch typing lets you keep watching what you write.
  2. Consistency. Touch typists pressed each key with the same finger more consistently, and they prepared upcoming keystrokes better, two of the habits linked to speed.
  3. The very top speeds. Touch typing is still the best-known route to very high speeds, and the researchers note that all typing world records are set with it.

The study also found limits to the classic system. Both groups slowed down by about half when typing random letter strings, and Feit pointed out that touch typing was developed for typing sentences on typewriters, not for things like software shortcuts or gaming with one hand on the mouse.

Breaking the visual habit

The researchers' tips for getting faster are simple: keep your hands still and move only your fingers, look at the screen instead of your fingers, and prepare upcoming keystrokes, starting with keys like Shift, Backspace, and Enter. Pressing each letter with the same finger every time also goes with higher speed. Be patient if you switch systems: the authors estimate that learning touch typing well enough to match a fast self-taught typist takes several hundred hours of deliberate practice.

To measure your baseline, take Typing Safari's free speed test, no account needed, then work through the lessons, which teach touch typing on your own keyboard.

FAQ

Can you type fast with hunt-and-peck?

Yes. In the 2016 Aalto University study, self-taught typists who used about six fingers on average typed as fast as trained touch typists, and some passed 70 WPM. They did, however, spend about twice as much time looking at the keyboard.

Why is 10-finger touch typing better than hunt-and-peck?

In the Aalto study it was not faster on average, but touch typists kept their eyes on the screen much more and pressed keys with more consistent fingers. Touch typing is also the best-known route to very high speeds: all typing world records use it.

How long does it take to switch to 10-finger touch typing?

It varies from person to person. The Aalto researchers estimate that touch typing to the level of a fast self-taught typist takes several hundred hours of deliberate practice, so expect steady progress over months rather than days.

Sources

More from the blog