Typing Safari · English

QWERTY's Real Story and the Typewriter-Jam Myth

· Typing Safari

QWERTY was not designed to slow typists down. The layout grew out of years of trial and error by Christopher Latham Sholes and his partners between 1868 and 1882, shaped by telegraph operators who needed to keep up with incoming Morse code, by the demands of investors and manufacturers, and finally by a company trying to get around old patents. Historians still disagree about how much jamming mattered, but the popular claim that the keys were scrambled to make people type slower has no support in the record.

It started out alphabetical, like a piano

The first machines did not look like keyboards at all. A patent granted on June 23, 1868 to C. Latham Sholes, Carlos Glidden and Samuel W. Soule of Milwaukee (US 79,265) describes keys laid out "similar to the keyboard of a piano." According to Koichi and Motoko Yasuoka of Kyoto University, who traced the layout through letters, patents and surviving machines, the Type-Writer the team shipped to Chicago in November 1868 had 28 keys arranged in alphabetical order: A to N running left to right, and O to Z running back right to left.

Its first customer was Edward Payson Porter, principal of Porter's Telegraph College in Chicago. The early typewriter was not built for office typists; professional typists did not exist yet. It was built for telegraph operators who listened to Morse code and wrote the messages down.

Telegraph operators shaped the letters

Porter wanted numerals on the machine so operators could take down Morse traffic. By April 1870 Sholes, helped by machinist Matthias Schwalbach, had a 38-key version with four rows, still nearly alphabetical. That September, Sholes and James Densmore demonstrated it in New York to George Harrington and Daniel Craig of the American Telegraph Works. One of Harrington's partners was a young Thomas Edison, who was not impressed: "The alignment of the letters was awful," he later recalled.

Harrington and Craig still promised to buy machines, but they asked for many improvements, including changes to the keyboard. When Scientific American put the Type-Writer on its front page on August 10, 1872, the engraving showed a 42-key layout in which about half the letters had moved.

The Yasuokas offer an intriguing explanation for one move, presented as their own reasoning rather than a documented decision. In American Morse code, Z sounds like the pair "SE," and operators often could not tell which they were hearing until more letters arrived. Placing S between Z and E let them reach either quickly.

From Remington to the QWERTY we use today

On March 1, 1873, Densmore signed a manufacturing contract with E. Remington & Sons in Ilion, New York. Remington's mechanics William Jenne and Jefferson Clough reworked the machine, and Sholes asked for Y to be moved to the center, next to T. The Sholes & Glidden Type-Writer went on sale in April 1874, and Serial No. 1 went to Anson Stager, president of Western Union in Chicago. Sholes later received a patent, US 207,559 (granted August 27, 1878), whose drawings include the keyboard.

In January 1878 Remington released the Type-Writer No. 2, which used Byron Brooks's shift mechanism so one key could print both a capital and a small letter. Its buyers were mostly shorthand writers, not telegraphers.

The final step came in 1882. A new sales company, Wyckoff, Seamans & Benedict, slightly altered the machine to steer clear of patents held by the Type Writer Company. On the keyboard, M moved next to N, and C and X swapped places. That, according to the Yasuokas, is the QWERTY layout as we know it. In 1893 five leading typewriter makers came together under the Union Typewriter Company, and by 1898 QWERTY had become the de facto standard. Teletype adopted it in the 1910s, and because Teletype machines served as computer terminals from the 1940s to the 1970s, computer keyboards inherited it.

The jam myth, and where historians disagree

The popular story goes like this: early typebars kept colliding, so Sholes spread common letters apart, deliberately making typing slower so the machine would not jam. Some writers have gone further and claimed QWERTY was "invented to slow down typing speed."

The slowing-down part is the myth. The Yasuokas point out that the early users were Morse receivers, who had to type as fast as the sender was transmitting. A keyboard designed to slow them down would have made the product useless to its first market. They also examined surviving Sholes & Glidden machines at the Smithsonian, the Milwaukee Public Museum and elsewhere. The most common English letter pair, TH, does sit on opposite sides of the basket, 180 degrees apart. But the second most common, ER, sits just 16 degrees apart, nearly next door, because Jenne and Clough deliberately moved R near E. If separating frequent pairs had been the goal, it was applied very unevenly.

Not everyone goes that far. Economists Stan Liebowitz and Stephen Margolis, who are otherwise fierce critics of QWERTY folklore, wrote that Sholes and his associates experimented with keyboard designs "in part to solve the problem of the jamming of the keys." So there are two claims here. That jamming was one concern during development is a view some historians still hold. That the layout was designed to make typists slower is a myth.

Did salesmen really type TYPEWRITER on the top row?

You can type the word TYPEWRITER using only the top letter row of a QWERTY keyboard. That neat fact gave rise to another legend: that R was moved up so salesmen could impress customers by pecking out the brand name. The economist Paul David repeated it in 1986, hedged with "it has been suggested," and Harvard's Stephen Jay Gould helped spread it around the world.

The Yasuokas are skeptical. The brand name had already been settled as "Sholes & Glidden Type-Writer" before R was moved, they note, so why not put SHOLES or GLIDDEN on one row? And sales demonstrations were done by taking down live Morse code or dictation, not by typing a single word. Treat it as a fun coincidence, not design history.

Is Dvorak really faster?

QWERTY's reputation as a "bad" layout owes a lot to the Dvorak Simplified Keyboard, patented by August Dvorak in the 1930s, and to a 1944 US Navy study said to show that retraining typists on Dvorak paid for itself within ten days. Liebowitz and Margolis challenged that story in their 1990 paper "The Fable of the Keys." In a 1996 Reason article summarizing their work, they reported that the Navy study had been conducted by Dvorak himself, according to Earle Strong of Pennsylvania State University, and that Dvorak held the patent. A later study Strong ran for the General Services Administration found that retrained Dvorak typists then improved more slowly than a matched group who received further QWERTY training, and he concluded that switching would never pay for itself.

Liebowitz and Margolis also take apart the famous Cincinnati contest of July 25, 1888, in which Frank McGurrin, typing on a QWERTY Remington, beat Louis Traub (often spelled Taub) on a Caligraph. They found reports of many other contests in 1888 and 1889, including wins on non-QWERTY machines. The fair summary: any Dvorak advantage appears small at most, and the dramatic claims rest on weak evidence.

What this means if you are learning to type

The real lesson of QWERTY history is that practice matters far more than layout. If you want to see where you stand, you can take the free speed test on Typing Safari without an account, and the full English course, every lesson and every game, is free with a free account.

FAQ

Why are the letters on a keyboard in QWERTY order?

QWERTY took shape between 1868 and 1882 through many small changes. Telegraph operators' needs, requests from investors and manufacturers, and a final tweak in 1882 to avoid existing patents all played a part. No single design principle explains every key.

Was QWERTY designed to stop typewriters from jamming?

Historians disagree about how much jamming influenced the layout. Some, like Liebowitz and Margolis, accept it as one factor, while the Yasuokas argue the typebar arrangement does not support it. Everyone agrees on one thing: it was not designed to slow typists down.

Who invented the QWERTY keyboard?

Christopher Latham Sholes is usually credited, working with Carlos Glidden, Samuel Soule, James Densmore and others. Remington's mechanics and, in 1882, Wyckoff, Seamans & Benedict made later changes.

Is the Dvorak keyboard faster than QWERTY?

The best-known evidence for a big Dvorak advantage, a 1944 Navy study, was reportedly run by August Dvorak himself. Later studies, including one for the US General Services Administration, found little or no advantage once both groups received equal training.

Can you really type TYPEWRITER on the top row?

Yes, all ten letters are on the top row of a QWERTY keyboard. The claim that this was planned for salesmen is an unproven story, and the Yasuokas argue against it.

Sources

More from the blog